Case · How to get rid of it

Do roof moss treatments really work?

The ruling

Yes. Roof moss treatments built on benzalkonium chloride, Wet & Forget and 30 Seconds among them, work on what their labels list when used as directed. They act on the growth on the day, but it stays anchored until the weather carries it off over months. The dose on every square metre, on every face, decides the result.

Do roof treatments work?

Yes. Most roof moss treatments on Australian shelves are built on one active constituent: benzalkonium chloride, a quaternary ammonium compound. Yates Surrender carries 500 grams a litre of it,1 and the safety data sheets for Wet & Forget Moss & Mould Remover and 30 Seconds Roof Treatment each list it at under 10 percent.2, 3 UNGROW Bailiff, the treatment we apply, is built on it too. Each of those makers lists moss, lichen and algae among what its product treats.1, 4, 5

The chemistry does what the labels say. Quaternary ammonium compounds are membrane active: they get into a cell's wall, disorganise the membrane beneath it, and the cell leaks its contents.6 In a laboratory test, a commercial benzalkonium chloride biocide severely impaired the photosynthesis of a lichen and a moss, with no recovery over the 21 days of the test, and the moss was the more sensitive of the two.7 Yates says that under the right conditions and application rates, "death will occur for algae and liverwort in minutes and moss and lichen within hours".8

In plain terms It works like detergent on grease, opening up the skin of every cell it reaches. A moss in that state does not recover, even though it sits on the roof looking much the same for weeks.

Does Wet & Forget really work?

On its maker's own terms, yes: on what it lists, used as directed, in the time it gives. Wet & Forget concentrate is mixed one part to five of water, sprayed onto a dry surface until it is thoroughly wet, and left. "Rinsing it off would stop the product from working," its maker says.4 It is a leave-on treatment: it works on the growth where it sits, and in its maker's words, "The wind and rain will work with the formula to clean the surface over time."4 So its maker's timelines are the ones to judge it by: its product page says green algae usually goes within days, black mould can take 2 to 4 months and heavy lichen 6 to 12 months,4 and its roof guide says black mould will noticeably improve within 6 to 8 months and lichen takes 8 to 12 months.9 For black mould, it says one application is normally sufficient; on a badly contaminated roof, it says to apply a second a month after the first.10 The FAQ for its hose end bottle has the line every reviewer should read first: "'Rapid' refers to the application speed, not the cleaning speed!"11

30 Seconds says the same of its roof treatment. Its directions say "DO NOT RINSE OFF", and some lichen, moss, mould and algae "may take up to 6-8 weeks to show any sign of decay", with heavily contaminated surfaces taking up to 6 months to come clean.5

Moss has no true roots, but it anchors with root-like rhizoids,12 and dead moss stays where it grew until the weather breaks it down and washes it off. That is why dead growth stays on the roof for months, and why a treatment that has worked looks, for its first weeks, exactly like one that has not.

In plain terms A leaf in autumn is dead well before the wind takes it off the branch. The growth ends on the day, and the weather decides when it lets go.

Wet & Forget and 30 Seconds reviews: why some say it did not work

When a quaternary ammonium biocide falls short in use, the fault is usually in the use. A review of these biocides found that "most problems turn out to be related to pseudoresistance or user error, such as overdilution or incorrect handling of the product".13 The makers' own directions show where.

  • Judged too soon. A roof that looks the same at three weeks is on schedule; the timelines above run to a year for heavy lichen.
  • Rain too soon. Wet & Forget wants no rain for at least 12 hours, "as premature rain can wash the product off before it has properly penetrated the growth".9
  • Too little on each square metre. Wet & Forget says the undulations in the tiles make a 150 square metre roof larger than 150 square metres to treat, and that lichen on a roof that size takes three 5 litre bottles of its concentrate.9
  • Cold weather. Yates says Surrender "does not work as effectively under cold weather conditions",14 and its data sheet says to apply it when conditions are warm.8 Perth's winter is cool rather than cold: July, the coldest month, still averages 18.5 °C by day at Perth Metro.15 When to treat in Perth, winter included, is in when is the best time to treat a roof in Perth.
  • One coat on heavy growth. For heavy infestations, Yates says repeat applications may be required,8 and 30 Seconds says the same of heavy growth.5 That is what our twelve month check is for: if the roof looks the same as the photo from the day, we treat it again, free.

In plain terms Most failed treatments are a good cake mix made with half the eggs, baked in a cold oven and taken out early. The packet was fine.

Dose per square metre and every face decide the result

Montana State University's guide to home and garden sprayers puts it plainly: "For pesticides to be effective, they must be applied uniformly at the recommended rates noted on the label."16 The makers give very different coverage figures for their own bottles, compared in roof moss products at Bunnings, and 30 Seconds says what its hose end covers depends on the water pressure and "the application style of the person using the product".17

Then there are the faces nobody sees from the lawn: the back of the roof and the far side of every valley. In most bryophytes, the group mosses belong to, the spores travel on the wind,12 so a face that is missed goes on seeding the rest. On engraved sandstone in Italy, monitored for 54 months, biocides applied after cleaning gave the best results through two growing seasons outside the deepest shade, and the regrowth came mainly from the uncleaned surfaces around each treated patch.18 The Roof Report shows your own roof from above, every face of it, and where moss and lichen settle first.

In plain terms Spray the weeds you can see from the kitchen window, leave the ones behind the shed, and by spring the shed side has seeded the garden again.

Roof moss treatment before and after: what a treated roof looks like

A real before and after of a leave-on treatment is months apart, not hours. These are field records of the same treatment: a terracotta roof carrying moss and lichen, photographed on the day, and again fifteen months later. Nobody went back up in between.

A terracotta tile roof dark with moss and lichen, seen from the street on the day of treatment
Exhibit A Day of treatment. Moss and lichen across a terracotta roof.
The same terracotta roof fifteen months later, its tiles back to red and orange
Exhibit B The same roof fifteen months later. The weather did the removal.

What happens between those two photos is in a treated roof, month by month, and When will it clear? works it through for your roof's faces and the month you treat. On the roofs we treat, growth starts coming away over 3 to 18 months, and moss lets go before lichen. Our field test roofs were treated three and a half years ago, with nothing done since, and they are still looking great.

A roof that looks clean by the afternoon has been washed, and a pressure jet is hard on the tiles: Monier, which makes roof tiles, "strongly advises against the use of pressure washers for roof cleaning", because they "pose a significant risk of tile damage".19 The other ways to deal with moss are in how to get rid of moss on a roof.

What a professional treatment changes

Not the chemistry. A retail bottle used exactly to its label works on what its label lists. What we change is everything above.

  • Measured. We measure the roof from aerial imagery of the address before the day, and mix UNGROW Bailiff to the label rate for that area, on a day with a dry forecast.
  • Every face. Bailiff goes on from the roofline, from ladders, with a low pressure soft wash pump through non-directional nozzles. Nobody walks on the roof, and the back faces and valleys get the same dose as the front. We spray around solar panels, not on them.
  • Guaranteed. We photograph the roof on the day from a fixed position. If it looks the same as that photo at twelve months, we treat it again, free.

Doing it yourself means getting the same dose onto the same faces from the top of a ladder. Wet & Forget tells its own customers to be harnessed to the roof and never to walk on a section they have just sprayed, because it stays slippery until it is dry.10 What a first treatment costs is in roof cleaning cost in Perth.

What this means for your roof

You get UNGROW Bailiff at the label rate on every face of your roof, put on from the roofline with nobody walking on it, and a check at twelve months against the photo from the day: if it looks the same, we treat it again, free. Roof moss treatments work; what decides your roof is that dose reaching every face on a dry day, then time for the weather, and that is the part we take off your hands. Growth recurs, so UNGROW Sentry, our preventative, keeps the roof treated after that.

Also asked

Will Wet & Forget get rid of moss on a roof?

Yes, used as its maker directs. Wet & Forget lists moss among what its concentrate treats: mixed one part to five of water and sprayed onto a dry roof until it is thoroughly wet, then left. It works on the day and shows over the months after, as the wind and rain carry the dead moss off. Its maker says rinsing it off would stop it working.

Does Wet & Forget work on black mould?

Yes. Its maker lists mould among what it treats and says black mould can take 2 to 4 months to go, and that one application is normally enough for it. Like every leave-on treatment, the roof looks the same on the day it is sprayed. The change comes as the weather works on the dead growth.

Is Wet & Forget or 30 Seconds any good?

Used exactly as its label directs, each works on what it lists. Both are built on benzalkonium chloride, both list moss, lichen, algae and mould, and both are leave-on treatments that act on the growth on the day and show over weeks and months. We do not rank one above the other: what decides your result is the dose on every square metre, every face covered, a dry day and time.

How does Wet & Forget work?

Its active is benzalkonium chloride, which breaks down the membranes of the cells in the moss, lichen, algae or mould it soaks into. Its maker says it acts on the growth as soon as it is applied, then works with the wind and rain to break the dead growth down over the months after. So it is left on: rinsing it off, its maker says, would stop it working, and it needs at least 12 hours without rain.

How much does a professional roof moss treatment cost?

A first treatment with UNGROW Bailiff is from $539 including GST. The price comes from your roof's area, measured from aerial imagery of the address, with set additions for a second storey, difficult access and outer suburbs. It is a fixed price, set before anyone comes out, and it includes the photo on the day and the check against it at twelve months.

Will the moss come back after treatment?

Staying treated is what keeps it off. A treatment clears the moss that is there, and moss spores travel on the wind, with the faces in shade giving them the best start, so a roof left alone is recolonised in time. We check the roof against the photo from the day at twelve months, and UNGROW Sentry, our preventative, keeps it treated after that.

On the record

  1. Yates / Hortag, Surrender Mosskiller label (10 L)
  2. Wet and Forget (Australia) Pty Ltd, Wet & Forget Moss & Mould Remover: safety data sheet (2016)
  3. 30 Seconds Ltd, 30 Seconds Roof Treatment Concentrate: safety data sheet (2019)
  4. Wet & Forget Australia, Remove Mould, Moss, Lichen & Algae Outdoor
  5. 30 Seconds Australia, Roof Treatment
  6. Clinical Microbiology Reviews (PMC), Antiseptics and disinfectants: activity, action, and resistance (1999)
  7. Stresses, Accumulation and Phytotoxicity of Two Commercial Biocides in the Lichen Evernia prunastri and the Moss Brachythecium sp. (2021)
  8. Yates Australia, Surrender Mosskiller: Technical Data Sheet
  9. Wet & Forget Australia, Roof cleaning information
  10. Wet & Forget Australia, Lichen or black mould on your roof?
  11. Wet & Forget Australia, Rapid Application Mould Removal inc Moss, Lichen & Algae
  12. Australian National Botanic Gardens, What is a bryophyte?
  13. Applied and environmental microbiology, Quaternary ammonium biocides: efficacy in application (2015)
  14. Yates, Yates Surrender Moss Killer
  15. Bureau of Meteorology, Climate statistics for Australian locations: Perth Metro (009225)
  16. Montana State University Extension, Calibrating Home and Garden Sprayers
  17. 30 Seconds Australia, Spray & Walk Away
  18. The Science of the total environment, Lithobiontic recolonization following cleaning and preservative treatments on the rock engravings of Valle Camonica, Italy: A 54-months monitoring (2023)
  19. Monier, Roof cleaning and maintenance

Get a price

Start with the address.

We price it off the address. No site visit, no two hour window, nobody walking through your house.

  1. 01You send the address.
  2. 02We look at the roof and send you a fixed price.
  3. 03To go ahead, tap Accept on the quote. We call you to pick a day.
  4. 04We treat it and photograph it the same day.
  5. 05We check it against that photo at twelve months.
  • Fixed price
  • Fully insured
  • 12 month guarantee

NOTICE TO VACATE

To

Moss, lichen, algae, mould

Leave by

Over the next 3 to 18 months

Evicted from the roofline.

Roof treatment · Western Australia