Case · Is it doing damage?

How do you know if your roof needs replacing?

The ruling

A roof needs replacing when it fails, not when it looks old. Leaks that keep coming back in more than one place, water damaged roof timber, clay tiles crumbling to dust, steel rusted through or an ageing asbestos cement roof point to replacement. A cracked tile or loose ridge is a repair. Faded colour needs nothing. Growth needs treating.

How to tell when it's time to replace a roof

Go by what the roof is doing, not how old it looks. BMI, which sells Monier roof tiles in Malaysia, puts it in one line: "Age alone does not determine when a roof needs replacing."1 Monier and Bristile, two Australian tile makers, both say leaks are mostly confined to small areas and come from the same short list: blocked gutters, valleys and downpipes, cracked mortar bedding under the ridge capping, cracked, broken or displaced tiles, blocked channels under the tile laps, and damaged flashings.2, 3 Every fix on that list is a repair.

BMI says a single leak after a storm usually means one failed tile, a dislodged ridge cap or failed sealant at one joint, and "These are repair situations." Replacement, it says, is the better long-term decision when leaks recur across several sections, the underlay has failed, the roof timber has moisture damage, or the material has reached its rated design life.1

In plain terms A flat tyre is a puncture repair. Four tyres worn through to the cords is a new set.

Five signs a roof needs a roofer, and when they mean replacing

  1. Water is getting in. One leak is usually one fault: why is my roof leaking? lists the usual ones. Leaks that keep coming back in more than one place, or roof timber wet long enough to be damaged, are where BMI says replacing becomes the better decision.1
  2. Tiles are cracked, slipped or missing. One cracked or missing tile can let a lot of water in during heavy rain.4 The fix is to replace it, or put it back in place.2 More in cracked roof tiles.
  3. The ridge is coming loose. Bedding holds the ridge caps in place and pointing seals the joints, and Monier says pointing can crack or loosen in the weather.5 The fix is to rebed or repoint.2
  4. Clay tiles are crumbling. Fretting is the tile wearing away into fine dust, and the Australian Roofing Tile Association says it can change a tile's texture and structural integrity over time. It lists moss and lichen among the common causes in older clay tiles, because they retain moisture and may damage the tile. Its advice: have it inspected, and ask the tile's maker about replacement.6
  5. Steel has rusted through. BlueScope's Colorbond warranty measures a roof sheet's life to corrosion to perforation, a hole through the sheet.7 BlueScope's answer to small rust like spots is swarf, installation debris that corrodes and stains.8 See does a Colorbond roof rust?

In plain terms Tiles and ridges are parts, replaced one at a time. When the material fails across the roof, patching stops paying.

What a bad roof looks like, and what only looks bad

What you see What it is What it needs
Cracked, slipped or missing tiles A broken or displaced tile A roofer, to replace or reset it2
Cracks or gaps in the mortar along the ridge Bedding or pointing failing A roofer, to rebed or repoint it2
Clay tiles wearing away to fine dust Fretting An inspection, and the tile maker6
Faded, matt or patchy concrete tiles The colour coat weathering Nothing. It is decorative2
A white or grey bloom on concrete tiles Efflorescence, salts from inside the tile Nothing. It weathers off2
Moss, lichen, a green film or black streaks Growth on the tile, with lichen threads reaching into clay9 A treatment

Monier calls the colour coat on a concrete tile "purely decorative", and says its fading "has no effect on the tiles performance or its structural adequacy".2 Its warranty treats fade as natural weathering, not a defect.10 The white bloom is covered in white spots on roof tiles. What causes each kind of damage, and how to spot it from the ground, is in what causes roof damage.

Concrete roof tiles on a Wembley roof with the red colour coat surviving only in patches over a grey surface, white treatment foam across them
Exhibit A Concrete tiles on a Wembley roof, on the day of treatment. A worn colour coat and growth make a roof look old from the street. Neither, on its own, is a reason to replace it.

Growth is not a reason to replace a roof, and not a reason to leave it. On clay roof tiles six to ten years old, electron microscopy found lichen threads penetrating the tile and filling its fissures and cracks.9 Moss washes down into the valleys, and when a valley blocks, the water backs up and can overflow into the roof space4; blocked valleys and gutters head Monier's list of leak causes.2 Left alone, growth feeds the blockages on that list. More in what growth does to a roof.

In plain terms A car with faded paint and a car with a rusted out floor both look old from the kerb. Only one of them is off the road.

Should I replace my roof if it's not leaking?

Usually not. A roof that keeps the water out, with sound tiles and firm ridges, is doing its job. Three kinds of roof are worth replacing before water shows inside:

  • An old asbestos cement roof. HealthyWA says most asbestos building products in WA are over 50 years old and nearing the end of their life, that many asbestos roofs are brittle and better replaced than cleaned or painted, and that moss and algal growth on the surface stop it being cleaned safely.11 We generally do not treat asbestos cement roofs; an asbestos professional is the first call. See can you pressure clean an asbestos roof in WA?
  • Clay tiles fretting across the roof.6
  • Steel rusted through, or roof timber damaged by water. Perforation is where BlueScope's warranty puts the end of a sheet's life7, and water damaged timber, BMI says, turns a roofing job into a structural one.1

In plain terms You replace a fence when the posts rot, not when the paint peels.

How old should your roof be before you replace it?

There is no set age; how long roof tiles last goes tile by tile. The Australian Roofing Tile Association says a modern tiled roof should have an effective life of at least 50 years.12 Monier says it is not uncommon for terracotta to give more than a century of service, and that concrete becomes stronger and less porous with age.2 Bristile warrants its concrete and clay tiles for 50 years from purchase13, and Monier backs tiles bought from 1 July 2026 for 30.2 A warranty is what the maker stands behind, not the date the roof wears out.

Time sets when the roof is checked, not when it is replaced. Monier: "Every five to seven years you should have your roof checked by an expert tradesperson."2 BMI adds a visual check every year from the ground.4 Asbestos cement is the exception, because there the age is the problem.

In plain terms A roof's birthday tells you when to have it looked at, not when to pull it off.

Roof restoration or replacement, in Perth and the hills

A roof restoration keeps the roof and mends and recoats it: broken tiles replaced, ridges rebedded and repointed, then primer and colour. A re-roof takes the old tiles and ridge off, checks the timbers and lays a new roof, and Monier pitches it at a roof that is "aged, damaged or no longer performing as it should".14 A roof that only looks tired needs neither, and a pigmented respray sold as a fix for leaks or growth is no fix for either. Monier says "respraying your roof is aesthetic only and will not repair your roof"2, and growth settles where rain, shade and aspect let it, as why roofs grow moss and lichen explains. A coat of colour changes none of them. Costs are in what a roof restoration costs in Perth, and the full comparison in restoration or treatment. If a roof restoration is offered at the door, Consumer Protection WA says to say no: an unsolicited approach carries a mandatory 10 day cooling-off period, in which no payment should be made and no work done.15

In the hills, Bickley averages 1,082 mm of rain a year against 727 mm at Perth Metro16, 17, and growth runs on wet time, as where Perth roofs grow most shows. Growth makes a hills roof look older than it is, and growth is a treatment job, not a new roof.

In plain terms Restoring is re-covering the couch, and replacing is buying a new one. Neither is the answer to a stain that comes out.

What this means for your roof

If the roof keeps the water out and its tiles and ridges are sound, it does not need replacing, however tired it looks. If what makes it look old is moss, lichen or black streaks, treat it before it adds to the repair list: we apply UNGROW Bailiff to tiled and Colorbond roofs alike, from ladders at the roofline, through a low pressure soft wash pump and non-directional nozzles, so nobody walks the tiles and nothing is forced under them, and the weather carries the dead growth off, month by month, as When will it clear? shows for your roof. A first treatment is from $539 including GST, and UNGROW Sentry, our preventative, keeps the roof treated after that. An asbestos cement roof is the exception: we generally do not treat those, and an asbestos professional is the first call. Run the Roof Report to see which faces of your roof stay wet longest, and put your address in below for a fixed price.

Also asked

Is it better to repair or replace a roof?

Repair, when the fault is local. Monier and Bristile, two Australian tile makers, both say leaks are mostly confined to small areas, from cracked tiles, failed ridge bedding, blocked valleys and gutters or damaged flashings, and every fix they give is a repair. BMI says replacement becomes the better decision when leaks recur across several sections, the underlay has failed, the roof timber is water damaged, or the material has reached its rated design life.

What are five signs that my roof needs to be replaced?

Leaks that keep coming back in more than one place. Roof timber that water has damaged. Clay tiles wearing away to dust across the roof. Steel rusted through to holes. An old, brittle asbestos cement roof, which HealthyWA says is better replaced than cleaned or painted. BMI adds a failed underlay and a roof at its rated design life. A cracked tile, a loose ridge, a faded coat or growth on its own is not one of them.

What does a damaged roof look like from the ground?

Tiles that are cracked, out of line or missing. Gaps or cracks in the mortar along the ridges and hips. Clay tiles wearing away to dust. On steel, rust that has eaten through the sheet. Inside, a stain on the ceiling after rain. BMI recommends a visual check every year from the ground, and Monier warns that even walking on a tiled roof risks damaging tiles. Fading and white bloom are not damage. Growth is a treatment job: lichen threads reach into clay tiles and moss clogs valleys.

Someone at my door says my roof needs replacing. What should I do?

Say no on the doorstep, and get the roof looked at on your own terms. Consumer Protection WA has warned of travelling traders pushing overpriced roof restoration jobs at the door, and says an unsolicited approach carries a mandatory 10 day cooling-off period in which no payment should be made and no work done. It advises several written quotes, references and examples of previous work. Ask what is failing: a cracked tile or a loose ridge is a repair, not a new roof.

Can a roof restoration fix a leak?

Only the repair part of it. Monier's fixes for a leak are rebedding or repointing the ridge capping, replacing cracked tiles, putting displaced ones back and clearing blocked valleys, gutters and tile laps. It says respraying a roof "is aesthetic only and will not repair your roof", and that the colour coat on a concrete tile is purely decorative. If the roof leaks, the repairs fix it. The paint changes the colour.

Does a roof need replacing after hail?

Usually not the whole roof. On a tiled roof, Monier and the Australian Roofing Tile Association both say storm damage means replacing the individual damaged tiles. On Colorbond, BlueScope says hail dents generally do not affect the roof's lifespan, unless deep dents on a low pitched roof pond water and dirt, or the sheet laps are bent enough to draw water in. After a big storm, have a roofer check it.

On the record

  1. BMI Malaysia (Monier), When to Replace Your Roof? 5 Key Signs for Homeowners
  2. Monier, FAQs
  3. Bristile Roofing, Concrete Roof Tiles Technical Manual (2025)
  4. BMI Malaysia (Monier), Roof Leak Causes and How Tile Roofs Prevent Them
  5. Monier, Roof cleaning and maintenance
  6. Australian Roofing Tile Association, Fretting in Clay Roof Tiles: A Consumer's Guide (2024)
  7. BlueScope, COLORBOND steel when used in the manufacture of roof sheets in Australian applications (sample warranty) (2026)
  8. BlueScope (COLORBOND steel), Frequently Asked Questions
  9. Scanning, Evaluation of the effect of lichens on ceramic roofing tiles by scanning electron microscopy and energy-dispersive spectroscopy analyses (2005)
  10. Monier Roofing (CSR Building Products), Warranty: Concrete Roofing Products (July 2026) (2026)
  11. HealthyWA (WA Department of Health), Asbestos in and around the home
  12. Australian Roofing Tile Association, Frequently Asked Questions
  13. Bristile Roofing, 50 Year Product Warranty terms and conditions (2025)
  14. Monier, Roof Replacement and Re-roofing
  15. Consumer Protection, Government of Western Australia, Roof repair conmen back targeting WA homes (2025)
  16. Bureau of Meteorology, Climate statistics for Australian locations: Bickley (009240)
  17. Bureau of Meteorology, Climate statistics for Australian locations: Perth Metro (009225)

Get a price

Start with the address.

We price it off the address. No site visit, no two hour window, nobody walking through your house.

  1. 01You send the address.
  2. 02We look at the roof and send you a fixed price.
  3. 03To go ahead, tap Accept on the quote. We call you to pick a day.
  4. 04We treat it and photograph it the same day.
  5. 05We check it against that photo at twelve months.
  • Fixed price
  • Fully insured
  • 12 month guarantee

NOTICE TO VACATE

To

Moss, lichen, algae, mould

Leave by

Over the next 3 to 18 months

Evicted from the roofline.

Roof treatment · Western Australia