Case · What is it?

Lichen, moss, algae or mould: how to tell them apart

The ruling

Go by shape and texture, not colour. Lichen is a crust, rosette or tuft anchored into the tile, and its acid etches it. Moss is a soft cushion that holds water against the roof. Algae is a thin green film. Mould is dark spots and streaks that follow the water. White bloom, soot and rust are not growth.

Why colour lets you down

People search by colour: orange lichen, green moss, black mould. It is a fine way in, and a poor way to decide. A lichen is grey or the colour of its fungus when it is dry, and turns brighter, often greener, when it is wet.1 Orange lichens get their colour from pigments made by the fungus.2 Mosses "aren't always small and they aren't always green".3 Cyanobacteria, whose colonies leave dark stains on roofing,4 are bluish green to khaki when moist and blackish when dry.5

So the same patch can be two colours in one week. Shape and texture hold still.

In plain terms Telling growth apart by colour is like telling cars apart by their paint. The shape tells you the make.

The four, side by side

Shape Up close Where it sits on a roof Dry versus wet
Lichen Crust, rosette or tuft Flat and crusty, or leafy lobes; a defined edge; looks stuck to the surface, not sitting on it Open faces, ridges and hips, along the laps Grey and stiff when dry; brighter, often greener, when wet
Moss Cushion Tiny leaves on stems; soft; stands up off the surface Laps, valleys, gutters, shaded faces Curled and dull when dry; green and full when wet
Algae Film No thickness you can feel; smooth or slightly powdery Damp, shaded faces, below drip lines Green, brighter when wet
Mould Spot or streak A stain with no texture; runs down the slope with the water Down from ridges, under trees, where water lingers Black when dry; can look dark green or khaki when wet

A roof often carries two or three of these at once, and the order they arrive in is its own file.

Lichen: the crust

A lichen is a fungus living with a photosynthetic partner, an alga or a cyanobacterium.6 It comes in three main growth forms: crust (crustose), leafy (foliose) and shrubby (fruticose).7 On the roofs we treat, crusts and leafy rosettes are the common ones. A crust is bound so tightly to the surface that its underside is never visible, with fungal threads growing down into the material to anchor it. Many of the leafy kinds anchor with rhizines, bundles of threads that penetrate the surface.7 Lime loving crusts on concrete tiles are often orange or yellow.8, 9 On the roofs we treat they are just as often grey, white or pale green. Every one is a flat, crusty patch with an edge, whatever its colour. More in the lichen suspect file.

In plain terms Lichen looks painted on. Moss looks planted.

Moss: the cushion

Moss is a plant, one of the bryophytes. It has leaves on stems, no true roots, and anchors itself with rhizoids.3 In dry places many mosses grow as dense cushions and curl up to sit out the heat, then become active again with as little water as fog or dew.3 Leafy liverworts, a close relative, have leaves on stems too, and many of the "mossy" plants people see are in fact liverworts.3 On a roof the difference changes nothing: the Surrender label lists liverwort alongside moss, algae and lichen.10 More in the moss suspect file.

In plain terms Press moss and it gives like a sponge. Press lichen and it is like pressing on dried paint.

Algae and mould: the film and the streak

The first colonists of a roof tile form a biofilm: bacteria, algae and fungi bound together in a thick protective matrix they make themselves, which matures into pigmented black or green spots.11 Where green algae dominate, it reads as a green film. On the Perth roofs we treat, algae mostly shows as green. Where dark cyanobacteria dominate, it reads as black. Research cited by the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory names one cyanobacterium, Gloeocapsa magma, as the most frequent cause of staining on roofing granules,4 and its pigments gradually turn a light roof dark brown or black, evenly or in streaks.12 Dead colonies build up as dark stains too, so a black streak is part living film, part residue.4

That dark film is what most people call mould, a loose word: in the roofing industry, "the terms algae and fungi are sometimes used interchangeably".4 One study of 230 biofilms on building exteriors in Europe and Latin America found fungi rarely on mineral surfaces and often on paint,4 which is worth knowing if a roof has been painted. More in the files on algae, mould and black streaks.

In plain terms The film is the slime on the glass of a neglected fish tank. The streak is the tide mark it leaves where water runs.

Not growth at all: the lookalikes

  • Efflorescence. Salts in concrete tiles rise to the surface and leave a whitish grey film. Monier, who make the tiles, say it is temporary and usually disappears naturally.13, 14 It is calcium carbonate, and it often weathers off in about two years.4 It is flat, even and edgeless, unlike a white crust lichen, which comes in round patches with a defined edge. More in white spots on roof tiles.
  • Soot. Combustion soot settles on roofs and darkens them.4 It has no texture, no edge and no pattern of its own.
  • Rust. Iron oxide stains roofing.4 A rust streak starts at a piece of metal, a fixing, a bracket, an old flashing, and runs down from it.
  • A clean stripe. Copper and zinc leach in rain and hold growth back below them, which is why a roof can stay clean below a copper or galvanised flashing.4, 15 The stripe is the absence of growth, not a stain.
  • A ghost. A pale patch the shape of a colony is where lichen used to be. Ghost marks have their own file.

Researchers separate stains from growth with a drop of fresh bleach, which lightens most biological stains but barely touches soot or iron.4 That means a ladder and a roof, though. Monier recommends against cleaning your own roof because of the risk of falls and of damaging tiles.13 From the ground, shape and edge settle most of it.

In plain terms A stain is a mark on the surface. Growth has thickness and an edge.

Why it matters which one

Each of the four works on a roof in its own way.

  • Moss holds water. Moss soaks up water fast and lets it go slowly: a fist sized clump on a tree trunk can hold as much as a sponge the same size,16 and on a roof that keeps the tile under it wet. It washes into the valleys with leaves and sediment, and a blocked valley backs water up until it can overflow into the roof space.17
  • Lichen anchors into the tile and etches it. On clay roof tiles six to ten years old, a University of Novi Sad team used electron microscopy and found lichen threads penetrating the tile and filling its fissures and cracks. They traced the lichen's attack on the ceramic to its oxalic acid, and named the calcium oxalate crystal it forms, whewellite, the "destructive crystal phase".18 The full case is in does lichen damage roof tiles.
  • The films prepare the ground. Researchers working on ceramic roof tiles write that the microbes' "metabolic activities profoundly alter the composition of tiles", and that their biofilms "promote the settlement of macroorganisms such as plants and mosses".11

The science of each is in what growth does to a roof.

For the treatment it matters less. Surrender's label gives its active as 500 g/L benzalkonium chloride and says the product is for control of moss, algae, lichen and liverwort on paths, roofs and other hard surfaces, with all four listed for tiled roofs in its directions.10 Wet & Forget says black mould treated with its product noticeably improves within 6 to 8 months.19 Benzalkonium chloride is the active in UNGROW Bailiff, our treatment, too. It matters for what happens next: each one clears at its own pace, and lichen, anchored into the surface, takes 8 to 12 months to decompose by that maker's figures.19

In plain terms Four kinds of weed, one spray. They just clear at different speeds.

What this means for your roof

Whichever of the four is on your roof, it is working on it: lichen anchored in the tile and etching it, moss holding water and packing the valleys, the films making way for moss. You do not need to name each one first, because Bailiff works on all of them, mixed to the label rate and measured to the roof's area. We apply it from the roofline with a low pressure soft wash pump through non-directional nozzles, so nothing is forced under tiles or laps, and the weather carries the dead growth off over the months that follow.

Also asked

Is lichen a type of mould?

No. Lichen is a fungus living in partnership with an alga or a cyanobacterium, and together they build a body with a skin, a structure and a shape of its own. Mould is a loose word for fungi growing as a film or spots. They can share a roof, and often do, but they are different things and they look different up close.

Is green moss a form of mould?

No. Moss is a plant, one of the bryophytes, with tiny leaves on stems and anchoring threads underneath. You can see its structure with the naked eye and press it like a sponge. A green film you cannot feel is more likely algae. A green crust stuck flat to the surface is more likely lichen.

Why is my roof discoloured?

Growth, or a stain that only looks like it. Growth is a green film of algae, or a dark film of cyanobacteria and fungi that darkens a light roof, evenly or in streaks; lichen, the crusty grey, white or coloured patches with a defined edge; or moss cushions in the laps and valleys. Stains are soot, rust running from a metal fixing and, on concrete tiles, efflorescence, a flat whitish film that usually fades by itself. A pale patch the shape of a colony is a ghost mark, where lichen used to be.

What is the black stuff on my roof?

Usually a living film of cyanobacteria and fungi, darkest where the water runs. Sometimes it is a dark lichen, which has a crusty edge, and occasionally it is soot, which has no texture and no edge at all. Our file on black streaks goes through the black stuff in detail.

What are the white spots on my roof tiles?

On concrete tiles, either a pale crust lichen or efflorescence. Lichen comes in round patches with a defined edge and a texture you could catch a fingernail on. Efflorescence is salt from the concrete itself, a flat, even whitish film with no edge, often across whole tiles, and it fades by itself.

Does it matter which one I have?

For the treatment, less than you would think. Benzalkonium chloride, the active in UNGROW Bailiff, works across all four. Surrender, built on it, lists moss, algae, lichen and liverwort together on its label, and Wet & Forget, on the same active, says black mould treated with it noticeably improves within 6 to 8 months. It matters for what you see next, because each one clears at its own pace and lichen, anchored into the tile, is the slowest to go.

On the record

  1. U.S. Forest Service, Lichen Biology
  2. Australian National Botanic Gardens, Lichen chemistry
  3. Australian National Botanic Gardens, What is a bryophyte?
  4. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Weathering of Roofing Materials: An Overview
  5. Australian National Botanic Gardens, What's not a lichen
  6. Australian National Botanic Gardens, What is a lichen?
  7. Australian National Botanic Gardens, Form and structure
  8. Australian National Botanic Gardens, Lichen habitats
  9. Australian National Botanic Gardens, Urban lichens in Canberra
  10. Yates / Hortag, Surrender Mosskiller label (10 L)
  11. Microorganisms, Methyl Potassium Siliconate and Siloxane Inhibit the Formation of Multispecies Biofilms on Ceramic Roof Tiles: Efficiency and Comparison of Two Common Water Repellents (2021)
  12. Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association, Algae discoloration of roofs
  13. Monier, Roof cleaning and maintenance
  14. Monier, FAQs
  15. Australian National Botanic Gardens, Pollution and lichens
  16. Australian National Botanic Gardens, Bryophyte ecology
  17. BMI Malaysia (Monier), Roof Leak Causes and How Tile Roofs Prevent Them
  18. Scanning, Evaluation of the effect of lichens on ceramic roofing tiles by scanning electron microscopy and energy-dispersive spectroscopy analyses (2005)
  19. Wet & Forget Australia, Roof cleaning information

Get a price

Start with the address.

We price it off the address. No site visit, no two hour window, nobody walking through your house.

  1. 01You send the address.
  2. 02We look at the roof and send you a fixed price.
  3. 03To go ahead, tap Accept on the quote. We call you to pick a day.
  4. 04We treat it and photograph it the same day.
  5. 05We check it against that photo at twelve months.
  • Fixed price
  • Fully insured
  • 12 month guarantee

NOTICE TO VACATE

To

Moss, lichen, algae, mould

Leave by

Over the next 3 to 18 months

Evicted from the roofline.

Roof treatment · Western Australia